POLL: What is your Religion?

[QuranSearchCom]

What is your Religion?

[There is only one God]

...

[zulfiqarchucknorris]

Im not shia but i agree that ther're muslims, they follow the pillars of islma, i think it would be better if you write sgiha islam instead of shia, it is like you are seperating islam with shiism, as if you are calling them unbelievers, as isn't that forbidden

[There is only one God]

.......................

[QuranSearchCom]

You have separated Islam with Shi'ism. I find that highly offensive.

As'salamu Alaikum dear brothers and sisters,

I am one that studied the shias sect very carefully.  Like some of you here, I used to consider them as Muslims.  Shias to me are divided into two:

1-  The liars and infidels among them.
2-  The ignorants.

Shias call unto creations of Allah Almighty for:

1-  Help.
2-  Protection.
3-  Guidance.
4-  Mercy.
5-  Forgiveness.

I have compiled an Arabic version of THEIR TOP SCHOLAS that proves this beyond any doubt.  You can't call unto Ali, or Fatimah, or anybody or any creation before you do something, nor to BEG THEM to accomplish something, and still call yourself a Muslim.  The shia scholars boldly justify this by saying that Allah is far and doesn't always hear us, nor is He always connected with us.  The people of the Bayt (House of the Prophet) are always connected to us and always listen to us and always intercede for us.  Total and utter blasphemy and nonsense!  Islam came to fight and end shirk (associating partners with Allah Almighty).  Even satan recognizes Allah Almighty is One, and Muhammad and all of the Prophets and Messengers are His Prophets and Messengers.  Now does that make satan a Muslim?

Furthermore, shias call Ali "Amir Al-Kawn", or the Amir (Leader, Ruler) of the Universe. Ask any shia scholar this question:  Who is Amir Al-Kawn?  His answer will always be Ali.  This is also blasphemy and an insult on Allah Almighty Himself.

Like I said, I used to be like you, who considered shias as Muslims.  But after I investigated them thoroughly, I couldn't possibly accept them as Muslims.  I will translate the Arabic video into English for you to see, insha'Allah.  You'll then see what I am talking about without any doubt.

Take care,
Osama Abdallah

[Tanveer]

Man, the pagans justified idols because they believed Allah was too far away aswell. -_-

[Black Muslim]

The same to me brother Osama . I have some comments .

"The shia scholars boldly justify this by saying that Allah is far and doesn't always hear us, nor is He always connected with us.  The people of the Bayt (House of the Prophet) are always connected to us and always listen to us and always intercede for us"

That's rude to God ! He says in Quran :

"And when My servants ask you, [O Muhammad], concerning Me - indeed I am near. I respond to the invocation of the supplicant when he calls upon Me. So let them respond to Me [by obedience] and believe in Me that they may be [rightly] guided."

Saying such things defies God's sayings .

"Islam came to fight and end shirk (associating partners with Allah Almighty)"

Just for knowledge , it's called polytheism . I guess you already know . But that's for the ones who don't talk in Arabic .

[RamziBinNabil]

Brother There is only One God, I don't want this to sound offensive, but why are you a Shi`a? I don't hate all Shi`a's man, don't worry. I know that, like Sunni's, there are some righteous ones and some mad men.

[There is only one God]

...

[Egyptian]

I hope our efforts be dedicated to its goal

answering-christianity

not wasting times answering the Islamic minor sects....


Christians are more than happy when watching muslim vs muslim disputes....

thanx...

[QuranSearchCom]

I despise hadith. More than that, I despise those who separate Shi'as despite the Qur'an specifically warning against the punishments for dividing the Muslims. After the 1500s, we started going backwards. One cause: Lack of unity. I'd rather leave Islam like I did before than be divided.

I don't know why you despise the Hadiths.  But it's important for you to know akhi that the Shias' hadiths collection came much much later than the Sunnis collections.  And the Sunnies have far more Hadiths than the Shias.

As to seperating the Muslims, my problem with the Shias is in their polytheism.  When they beg and pray to creations of Allah Almighty for:

1-  Help.
2-  Protection.
3-  Guidance.
4-  Mercy.
5-  Forgiveness.

then that's something I just can't ignore as a Muslim.  I am currently translating my Arabic video about them into English as I am typing this post (I took a break).  Once I am done, insha'Allah, I will upload it and let you know.  You see with your eye and you tell me if they're Muslims or not after you watch what THEIR TOP SCHOLARS SAY AND DO AKHI.  Deal?  Most Muslims are just plain ignorant of what the Shias really are.

Take care,
Osama Abdallah

[Egyptian]

Actually not only many of Shia practice such kind of shirk ,but also the sufi sect as well ....
They missed the true meaning of pure monotheism which necessarily requires directing the worship to Allah alone ,without any mediator ...

he is the only Helper, Protector,merciful,forgiver ,whether in heaven or on Earth.

still our duty as Sunnis who follow the path of the prophet peace be upon him and his companions may Allah bless their souls ,to remind such minor sects with  such basic goal of Islam (to abolish shirk in all its form) ,in a civil way , never calling them polytheists ,as long as they are not aware of what shirk means....

I know many shia abstained from such practices after sincere advices ....

 Holy Quran   3:159 It is part of the Mercy of Allah that thou dost deal gently with them Wert thou severe or harsh-hearted, they would have broken away from about thee: so pass over (their faults), and ask for (Allah's) forgiveness for them; and consult them in affairs (of moment). Then, when thou hast taken a decision put thy trust in Allah. For Allah loves those who put their trust (in Him).

[zulfiqarchucknorris]

although the shia are misguided they are, technically, still muslims since they only worship the one God

[QuranSearchCom]

although the shia are misguided they are, technically, still muslims since they only worship the one God

No they're absolutely not!  Like you dear brother, I used to defend the shias with a great passion.  But after I studied their religion carefully, I saw that it's 100% polytheism.  Just please give me till tomorrow to upload the English version of the video, and then YOU DEAR BROTHERS AND SISTERS TELL ME AFTER THAT whether the shias are Muslims or not.  Deal?

By the way, I don't consider the ignorant ones among them as polytheists.  But their leaders, imams and religion are 100% polytheist, and YOU'LL SEE THAT BY YOURSELVES, and you yourselves will tell me that yes they are.  Insha'Allah.  Just give me till tomorrow please.

Take care,
Osama Abdallah

[QuranSearchCom]

As'salamu Alaikum dear brothers and sisters in Islam,

Please visit: http://www.answering-christianity.com/shia_kufur_in_english_part_1.wmv.  This is part 1.  In Parts 2 and 3 you'll see how they say the most despicable things that they say about the Glorious Quran!  They also call it "their Quran", and not "our Quran".  Our Holy Quran is a corrupt book to them.

I want you to tell me how IN ALLAH ALMIGHTY'S HOLY NAME do you still call them Muslims after seeing minute 08:17 in this video!  Could any Sunni scholar dare to say anything like this on TV??  Yet, their top scholars say these things on their TVs, and they have successful TV programs too.

As always, all criticisms are more than welcomed with me.  Please speak your minds freely, dear brothers and sisters in Islam.  If you feel I am very wrong, then please say so.

Take care,
Osama Abdallah