An advice to brother Osama

[IA]

...

[abdullah]

Assalamualykum brother,
you said
 

if a sahih hadith goes in contradiction with what Islam teaches, it must have an explanation, and we should not reject it.

I have recently been learning about the science of hadith and one of the conditions of accepting ahadith is that if the hadith contradicts the Qur'an or established sunnah it is to be rejected.
Also, if the hadith contradicts reason, the compilers of hadith would throw away the hadith.

[IA]

...

[abdullah]

Assalamualykum
Thank you for clarifying your point, I agree with your explanation of the hadith about the bewitchment of the prophet, but the way i see it is that a muslim can either choose to accept or reject the hadith as it doesn't effect our faith or the laws of Islam.

[Black Muslim]

but the way i see it is that a muslim can either choose to accept or reject the hadith as it doesn't effect our faith or the laws of Islam.

A very wrong statement I must say ! How will you prayif you don't accept Hadith for example ? How can you say it doesn't affect faith while Allah orders us to follow the teachings of the prophet peace upon him which are from Allah by the way ?

[abdullah]

Assalamualykum

but the way i see it is that a muslim can either choose to accept or reject the hadith as it doesn't effect our faith or the laws of Islam.


A very wrong statement I must say ! How will you prayif you don't accept Hadith for example ? How can you say it doesn't affect faith while Allah orders us to follow the teachings of the prophet peace upon him which are from Allah by the way ?

I was referring to the hadith about the bewitchment of the prophet (SAWS). I am not a hadith rejecter.

[FARHAN_UDDIN]

Assalamualykum.

 Welcome to Answering Christianity brother  Ilir Ahmeti.

 May Allah shower His unending blessings upon you, your family and the entire Muslim Ummah. Ameen.

[QuranSearchCom]

As'salamu Alaikum dear brother Ilir and to everyone,

Thank you for the advise, dear brother.  May Allah Almighty bless you.  Ameen.  Please visit this post that I wrote before.  It should clarify much about where I stand concerning the Hadiths collections:

http://www.answering-christianity.com/blog/index.php/topic,1166.msg4047.html#msg4047

And again, this is why what agrees with the Holy Quran from both the Hadiths and also the Bible and other Scriptures we accept as closest to the Truth, but not absolute Truth like the Holy Quran, and what disagrees with the Holy Quran we reject.

Take care,
Osama Abdallah