Wikislam is not an Islamic Site!!!!

[mclinkin94]

Asalamu Alaikum:

I have been on that website and I initially thought that it was an Islamic reference site. It is the complete opposite! I'm sure others have seen it, it is the first website that I see when I search for anything islamically related. It strays people from Islam.

Does anyone know a site that refutes wikiislam? If not, should we create one with the same format so it is easy for non-muslims seeking guidance to see.

This is ridiculous and will not help the progression of God's religion.

This one seems to be the most misleading, they misinturpret so much and I am extremely angry about this:
http://wikiislam.net/wiki/Scientific_Errors_in_the_Qur'an

As we can all see, they misinterpret the Quran, put it out of context and then present scientific facts that refute the misinterpreted texts. This is an intelligent and deceptive tactic!

The reason I asked this is because I believe action should be done against this site. Maybe creating a site like it that refutes everything the wikiislam has in the order wikiislam posted it.

[Tanveer]

Asalamu Alaikum:

I have been on that website and I initially thought that it was an Islamic reference site. It is the complete opposite! I'm sure others have seen it, it is the first website that I see when I search for anything islamically related. It strays people from Islam.

Does anyone know a site that refutes wikiislam? If not, should we create one with the same format so it is easy for non-muslims seeking guidance to see.

This is ridiculous and will not help the progression of God's religion.

This one seems to be the most misleading, they misinturpret so much and I am extremely angry about this:
http://wikiislam.net/wiki/Scientific_Errors_in_the_Qur'an

As we can all see, they misinterpret the Quran, put it out of context and then present scientific facts that refute the misinterpreted texts. This is an intelligent and deceptive tactic!

The reason I asked this is because I believe action should be done against this site. Maybe creating a site like it that refutes everything the wikiislam has in the order wikiislam posted it.

Indeed. I think it's a site owned by Ali Sina or someone. If i remember correctly Bro Osama has made a wikiislaam.net to counter it. Dunno if it's made any progress though.

[Black Muslim]

it is the first website that I see when I search for anything islamically related

Are you sure you don't LOOK for it meaning to find it ? Because I don't when I type "Islam" in Google :
https://www.google.com.sa/search?client=firefox-a&hs=y2V&rls=org.mozilla%3Aen-US%3Aofficial&q=Islam&oq=Islam&gs_l=serp.3..35i39j0l9.47805.48380.0.48613.5.5.0.0.0.0.176.417.2j2.4.0...0.0...1c.1.14.serp.2nJd6ah6rDI

This one seems to be the most misleading, they misinturpret so much and I am extremely angry about this:

So let me get this straight , you're angry about this site and don't want people to visit it because it's clearly a dumpster , but now you bring a direct link to it ?! For the 8694359852 time : Stop advertising for garbage dumps

This is an intelligent and deceptive tactic!

Correcting , it's a sneaky , sly , malicious , filthy , evil tactic .

[mclinkin94]

"So let me get this straight , you're angry about this site and don't want people to visit it because it's clearly a dumpster , but now you bring a direct link to it ?! For the 8694359852 time : Stop advertising for garbage dumps"


Its not 'clearly' a dumpster, people fall for it! I have a friend in which his faith in Islam was weakened because of that site, he showed it to me and I think ACTION NEEDS TO BE TAKEN.

Thats the reason I posted.

[Sama]

Brother, i agree with you -most its points are already answered but we need answers for its points because of it's -apparently- professional appearance-but misleading info for those with superficial islamic knowledge..

[The Canadian Atheist]

lol. "Wiki" should've been a major giveaway

[Sama]

http://muslimwiki.com/mw/index.php/Muhammad

This site is islamic one but needs more additions

[Black Muslim]

Its not 'clearly' a dumpster, people fall for it!

And you're helping MORE people fall for it !!

[mclinkin94]

Its not 'clearly' a dumpster, people fall for it!

And you're helping MORE people fall for it !!

No I am trying to combat that website so people don't fall for it in the future.

[Black Muslim]

No I am trying to combat that website so people don't fall for it in the future.

Good , just do it without giving links to it . If you want people to beware of a certain place would you tell them (Don't go there , it is dangerous . But here is the way to it if you want to) ?
Am I clear ?

[Sama]

Its not 'clearly' a dumpster, people fall for it!

And you're helping MORE people fall for it !!

No I am trying to combat that website so people don't fall for it in the future.

Brother, if you want a rebuttal to particular point, please copy their allegation & post it in new thread