9 - Although that the mentioned woman was the same as the last one , the narration is weak . And here's a hint , once you see the name of "Al-Waqidy" in a narration , throw it in the garbage as he is infamous for being a liar and a fabricator . The same would be said about "Abu Al-Faraj Al-Asfahany" .
1. al-Shafi’i (d. 204 A.H.):
All the books of al-Waqidi are lies. In Madinah there were seven men who used to fabricator authorities, one of which was al-Waqidi.[11]
2. Ahmad ibn Hanbal (d. 241 A.H.):
He is a liar, makes alternations in the traditions.[12]
3. al-Nasa’i (d. 303 A.H.):
The liars known for fabricating the Hadith of the Messenger of Allah are four. They are: Arba’ah b. Abi Yahya in Madinah, al-Waqidi in Baghdad, Muqatil b. Sulayman in Khurasan and Muhammad bin Sa’id in Syria.[13]
4. al-Bukhari (d. 256 A.H.):
al-Waqidi has been abandoned in Hadith. He fabricates Hadith.[14]
5. al-Dhahbi (d. 748 A.H.):
Consensus has taken place on the weakness of al-Waqidi.[15]
6. Yahya ibn Ma’in (d. 233 A.H.):
He is weak. He is nothing. Not reliable![16]
7. Ishaq ibn Rahwiyah (d. 238 A.H.):
According to my view, he is one of those who fabricate Hadith.[17]
8. Abu Dawud (d. 275 A.H.):
I do not write his Hadith and I do not report (Hadith) on his authority. I have no doubt that he used to make up Hadith.[18]
9. Ibn Abi Hatim al-Razi (d. 277 A.H.):
He fabricates Hadith. We have abandoned his Hadith.[19]
10. al-Darqutni (d. 385 A.H.):
There is weakness in him (in his reporting).[20]
11. ‘Ali ibn Madyani (d. 241 A.H.):
He fabricates Hadith.[21]
12. Ibn ‘Adi (d. 365 A.H.):
His traditions are not safe and there is danger from him (in accepting his traditions).[22]
13. Ibn Hajr (d. 852 A.H.):
He has been abandoned in spite of vastness of his knowledge.[23]
14. Abu Zar’ah al-Razi (d. 264 A.H.):
Abandoned, Weak![24]
15. al-Nawawi (d. 676 A.H.):
Their (muhaddithin’) consensus is that al-Waqidi is weak.[25]
References:
[11] Ibn Abi Hatim, vol.4 pt.1 p.21
[12] al-Dhahbi, Mizan, vol.3 p.110
[13] Ibn Hajr al-‘Asqalani, Tahdhib al-Tahdhib, vol.9 p.366 No.604, Hyderabad, 1326 A.H.cf. Yusuf ‘Abbas Hashmi, Zaynab bint Jahash, ‘Islamic Culture’ vol.XLI, No.1, Hyderabad (India), 1967
[14] al-Dhahbi, Mizan, vol.3 p.110
[15] Ibid., p.111
[16] Ibid. p.110,
Ibn Abi Hatim, vol.4 pt.1. p.21
[17] Ibn Abi Hatim, p.21
[18] Ibn Hajr, Tahdhib, vol.9, p.366, No.604 cf. Hashmi
[19] Ibid., p.366
Ibn Abi Hatim, p.21
[20] al-Dhahbi, Mizan, p.110
[21] Ibid., p.110
Ibn Hajr, Tahdhib, p.366 cf. Hashmi
[22] al-Dhahbi, Mizan, vol.3, p.110
[23] Ibn Hajr, Taqrib al-Tahdhib, vol.2, p.194, Cairo, 1960
[24] Ibn Abi Hatim, vol.4, pt.1, p.21
[25] Ibn Hajr, Tahdhib, vol.9, p.366 cf. Hashmi
