166
GENERAL TOPICS | BOARD ANNOUNCEMENTS / Re: Does the Mafia act like Islam
« on: July 19, 2016, 03:17:16 AM »
Regarding Jizaya, by the same argument every state in the world acts like a "Mafia". If you do not pay money to the state, it jails you. In other words, you are safe or have freedom as long as you continue to pay.
I do not know if this was a common practice or not, but from what I've read, early Muslim Caliphs even used to pay back the money if they were unable to protect the minorities which is not something modern states practice. Additionally, modern states "forcefully" take money from the minorities and at the same time also expect them to join the army, protect the country and if need be give their lives too.
Regarding, men being over women, this is something that over centuries gradually started happening and taking root, so much so that in today's Muslim societies the practices have become so culturally ingrained that it will take some time to get rid of. For example, it took about 5 centuries for the prohibition on women from attending congregational prayers to became absolute. This in-spite of the presence of clear Prophetic narrations prohibiting Muslim men from making exactly such restrictions. After a thousand years, the average Muslim doesn't even know that women and men both used to attend congregation prayers in the first Muslim society.
Regarding, "Islam kills people who leave the religion" whether Muslims of today like it or not, this is something a lot of classical Muslim scholars have believed in. It doesn't have any proof from the Qur'an and in-fact it appears to even contradict this but some narrations of the Prophet have been interpreted in such a manner.
I do not know if this was a common practice or not, but from what I've read, early Muslim Caliphs even used to pay back the money if they were unable to protect the minorities which is not something modern states practice. Additionally, modern states "forcefully" take money from the minorities and at the same time also expect them to join the army, protect the country and if need be give their lives too.
Regarding, men being over women, this is something that over centuries gradually started happening and taking root, so much so that in today's Muslim societies the practices have become so culturally ingrained that it will take some time to get rid of. For example, it took about 5 centuries for the prohibition on women from attending congregational prayers to became absolute. This in-spite of the presence of clear Prophetic narrations prohibiting Muslim men from making exactly such restrictions. After a thousand years, the average Muslim doesn't even know that women and men both used to attend congregation prayers in the first Muslim society.
Regarding, "Islam kills people who leave the religion" whether Muslims of today like it or not, this is something a lot of classical Muslim scholars have believed in. It doesn't have any proof from the Qur'an and in-fact it appears to even contradict this but some narrations of the Prophet have been interpreted in such a manner.